IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON AUTOMATION SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING

A PUBLICATION OF THE IEEE ROBOTICS AND AUTOMATION SOCIETY

Review form for REGULAR and SHORT papers (Confidential when completed)

Instructions For Reviewers

If you close your Web-Browser before submitting, your data will be lost and nothing will be sent to us.

Also, we have noticed that our web-based review system does not work with Netscape 6.0. While we are trying to find a solution, please use Internet Explorer, Netscape 4.*, Netscape 6.1 or above.

Please fill in your information.  A copy of the completed document will be sent to this address as well as to us.  Keep this e-mail message until we have confirmed receipt of your copy. Please type the review directly and do not "copy and paste" from another editor.

Reviewer's Name

e-mail

Affiliation

Phone

Fax

Address

Originally Assigned Reviewer's Name

Originally Assigned Reviewer's e-mail

Check this "cc box" if you want this review to be copied to the originally assigned reviewer


Paper No.

Paper Type

Title

Authors

Referee Code

Requested Return Date

To


Assessment

Please rate the paper according to the following criteria, on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the highest rating.

Technical Quality

Relevance

Significance

Originality

Presentation

Adequacy of Citations

Overall

 

 

Other factors (identify)


Recommendations

ACCEPT as a REGULAR or

ACCEPT as a SHORT paper provided that all typographic errors and minor recommendations are corrected in the final draft.

Should this paper be considered for the BEST PAPER AWARD?

Yes

No

CONDITIONALLY ACCEPT as a REGULAR or

CONDITIONALLY ACCEPT as a SHORT paper, provided that minor revisions are made as indicated in the "Comments to Authors" on the next page. (The editors may decide to request reviewers' assistance in verifying the changes.   If you believe reviewer verification to be especially important, please indicate in the "Confidential Comments" below. )

REVISE AND RESUBMIT as REGULAR or

REVISE AND RESUBMIT as SHORT paper as indicated in the "Comments to Authors" on the next page.

REJECT THE PAPER (Future submissions of this work to the Transactions will be treated as substantially new papers.   Depending on circumstances, the editors may choose to include previous reviews of the rejected paper in any subsequent review of revised versions. )

Submit to another journal


Confidential Comments (for Associate Editors and Editors only)

 


Comments to Authors

Major Contribution of the Paper

 

Organization and Style

 

Technical Accuracy

 

Presentation

 

Adequacy of Citations (List possible additions if needed)

 

When you have completed your review, please click the "Submit" button.

 

If you close your Web-Browser before submitting, your data will be lost and nothing will be sent to us.

If error happened during submission, please contact Peter Luh or System Administrator